Ranger 1 wrote:I agree that hiring mercs isn't likely to save you from a suicide gank.
Trying to mine while at war is another topic entirely.
First, if you are under a war dec worrisome enough to hire merc's you shouldn't be mining to begin with. You should be prepared to assist your merc's in ending the war dec.
Second, if your mercs assure you that their scouts can alert you before any war targets enter system, and IF they don't mind you playing target, that's fine. Get assurances. Then fit your Hulks to ensure you can get your butt out of the belt when the scout alerts you. Even then you need to be aware that the people at war with you are perfectly capable of suicide ganking you with neutral alts.
Again, merc use vs suicide gank and merc use vs war dec are two completely different things. Either way, you should be prepared to participate on your own behalf as best you can unless your mercs request otherwise.
Well in a wardec the attackers would not even need to suicide gank. They'd just need to do their job (call it suicide) before the mercs bring them down, if they do.
See, I reason by objectives.
Wardec from competitor corp means they want to disrupt my income / production / cycle / whatever.
If I don't spend a nickel, they will succeed at that. Till now it's all linear.
Now enter the new wardec mechanic. It should kinda be a "version 2" of the current system, i.e. have less open holes and more effectiveness at what covers.
What happens is that with the new wardec mechanic, I would be unable to dec shield (which is OK) but even using the new mechanic and paying a merc corp for me, the attackers STILL disrupt the income, production, cycle and whatever.
I mean, what's the point of a new mechanic if it does not introduce a new dimension of gameplay?
I want to be able to pay well and be
defended in my interests. I mean, the PvP will happen so both attackers and defending mercs are happy (which is all nice and dandy) but I just paid for
others to have fun (less nice but still OK) while I don't reap a single benefit (the part that I am not OK with).
Imagine what would happen in RL if you pay mercs to defend your camps / your cargo ships (vs sea pirates), the mercs shoot and "win" yet you lose both your camps and your ships. How longer would anybody care to still hire mercs if they lose all anyway?
Translated into EvE terms, how longer till industry corps (the huge majority of war targets) realize it's pointless to get defenders and thus make the whole new mechanic sit unused, while the industry corpies still stay docked for the wardec duration like now?